Yo, >>22, I appreciate this thread and your effort, but you are thoroughly mistaken in your judgement of what came to be known as "11.5".
I, obviously, don't claim any objectivety and, in fact, very biased in this matter. And certainly will refrain from opening any of the two ever again. But as I remember it, for the first evening it was 2.5 people competing in posting speed ensuring abhorrent quality of both.
It was a very interesting personal experience, however.